Listen to this Deep Dive, 13 min, read by Simon

Emotional Intelligence Series

I have met people who seem to possess an extraordinary talent for saying exactly the right thing. They listen attentively, recognize emotional cues, acknowledge other people’s feelings, and respond with a level of sensitivity that can make even difficult conversations feel remarkably comfortable. They understand the language of empathy and have learned how to communicate in ways that leave others feeling valued.

Yet occasionally, something about these interactions leaves me unconvinced.

The words are appropriate, the manner reassuring, and the emotional intelligence apparently impressive. But when circumstances become difficult, the understanding disappears. Promises are forgotten, apologies produce little change, and the person who seemed so attentive becomes strangely unavailable when genuine accountability is required.

I used to think sincerity was simply a quality people either possessed or lacked. Some individuals were naturally genuine, while others were better at managing impressions. Experience has complicated that view.

I now think sincerity is partly a skill, something that can be developed through self-awareness, emotional discipline, honest communication, and repeated practice. And like most worthwhile skills, it becomes considerably more demanding when the circumstances are uncomfortable.

Why Good Intentions Are Not Enough

Most people probably consider themselves sincere. They believe their expressions of concern are genuine, their promises are made in good faith, and their apologies reflect an honest desire to repair relationships.

Yet sincerity involves more than what we intend to communicate.

Consider someone who promises to help a colleague with an important project. At the moment the promise is made, they genuinely want to help. They appreciate the colleague’s difficulty and feel pleased to offer reassurance. Unfortunately, they have not considered their existing commitments, the time involved, or whether they can realistically deliver.

A few days later, the promise becomes an obligation they resent. Eventually, they disappoint the very person they were trying to support.

Were they sincere when they offered to help? Perhaps. But their sincerity lacked the judgment necessary to make it dependable. Zenger Folkman’s research on 162,000 leaders, When Leaders Keep Their Word (And When They Don’t), shows how much damage broken commitments do to a leader’s effectiveness.

This is an important distinction because emotional intelligence should help us understand our own motivations before we communicate them to others. Sometimes we promise because we care. Sometimes we promise because disappointing someone in the present feels more uncomfortable than disappointing them later.

A sincere intention that repeatedly produces unreliable behavior eventually becomes difficult to distinguish from insincerity.

The Skill of Knowing What You Actually Mean

One of the foundations of sincerity is developing enough self-awareness to recognize what we genuinely think and feel before trying to communicate it.

That is harder than it sounds.

Human beings are remarkably capable of constructing explanations for their behavior that make them feel better about themselves. We describe our reluctance to disagree as diplomacy, our desire for approval as kindness, and our tendency to avoid difficult conversations as patience.

Sometimes those descriptions are accurate. Occasionally, they conceal motives we would rather not examine.

Emotional intelligence requires the willingness to look beneath our preferred explanations. When we agree with someone, are we genuinely persuaded, or are we uncomfortable with disagreement? When we apologize, do we understand the harm we caused, or are we simply trying to end an unpleasant conversation?

These questions matter because sincerity cannot reliably emerge from an internal world we have made little effort to understand.

The ability to communicate sincerely begins with the willingness to stop misleading ourselves about what we actually mean.

That kind of self-awareness develops through reflection, experience, and a willingness to accept feedback that challenges our preferred interpretation of our behavior. Organizational psychologist Tasha Eurich explains the difference between knowing ourselves and knowing how others see us in Harvard Business Review’s What Self-Awareness Really Is (and How to Cultivate It).

Listening Without Managing the Outcome

There is another dimension of sincerity that I believe deserves more attention: the ability to listen without immediately trying to control where the conversation goes.

Many people are technically excellent listeners. They maintain eye contact, ask thoughtful questions, and acknowledge what the other person has said. But underneath that apparently attentive behavior, they are already preparing their response. Jack Zenger and Joseph Folkman’s study of good listeners in Harvard Business Review, What Great Listeners Actually Do, found that the best listeners act less like sponges and more like trampolines, engaging with what they hear rather than waiting for their turn.

They may be deciding how to defend themselves, resolve the disagreement, restore approval, or persuade the other person to see things differently.

Their attention is divided between understanding the person speaking and managing the emotional outcome.

Genuine listening requires tolerating the possibility that what we hear may be inconvenient. Someone may have a legitimate criticism of our behavior. Their disappointment may be entirely reasonable. Their interpretation may reveal something about us that we have not previously recognized.

An emotionally mature person can remain present long enough to consider that possibility without immediately trying to make it disappear.

This does not require agreeing with every accusation or accepting someone else’s perception as unquestionable fact. Sincerity also involves being honest when we disagree.

But there is something profoundly reassuring about speaking with someone who appears genuinely interested in understanding us rather than simply moving the conversation toward a conclusion that suits them.

Sincerity Becomes Difficult When It Costs Something

The real challenge with sincerity is that people frequently understand what honesty requires but struggle with the consequences of practicing it.

It is relatively easy to express appreciation, encouragement, and affection. More difficult is telling someone that we cannot meet their expectations, that we disagree with their interpretation, or that we have made a decision they will find disappointing.

These are the moments when sincerity becomes a discipline.

A manager who genuinely respects an employee must sometimes deliver difficult feedback. A friend who values a relationship may need to establish boundaries. A leader who believes in transparency must occasionally acknowledge that a previous decision was mistaken.

The temptation in each case is to soften the message until the difficult truth becomes almost impossible to recognize.

I understand that temptation. Nobody particularly enjoys disappointing someone they care about, and there is nothing admirable about unnecessary bluntness.

But emotional intelligence should help us communicate difficult truths responsibly, rather than provide increasingly sophisticated ways to avoid them.

Sincerity sometimes requires accepting another person’s disappointment instead of purchasing their approval with something we do not genuinely mean.

That is an uncomfortable skill to develop, particularly for people who have built their identities around being agreeable, helpful, or universally liked.

The Leadership Test

In organizational life, sincerity has consequences extending well beyond individual relationships.

Leaders increasingly understand the importance of empathy, psychological safety, and emotionally intelligent communication. These are welcome developments. But they have also created opportunities for leaders to become exceptionally fluent in the language of care without necessarily changing how they behave.

An executive can speak convincingly about accountability while remaining defensive when challenged. They can acknowledge employees’ concerns in beautifully composed communications while allowing the underlying problems to continue.

Employees notice these contradictions, even when they are reluctant to discuss them openly.

I have found that people are often more forgiving of an awkward but sincere leader than of an exceptionally polished executive whose words repeatedly exceed their actions.

The awkward leader may struggle to find the perfect expression, but employees understand where they stand. The polished executive may provide immediate reassurance while leaving everyone uncertain about what will actually happen.

Sincerity in leadership therefore requires more than emotional awareness. It demands an ability to connect intentions, communication, decisions, and subsequent behavior.

And when those things become misaligned, the leader must be willing to acknowledge the inconsistency without producing an elaborate explanation for why it should not matter.

Trust Is Built Through Repeated Evidence

One of the reasons sincerity is difficult to fake indefinitely is that trust develops through accumulated experience.

We become confident in someone’s sincerity when their behavior repeatedly supports what they tell us. They keep commitments, acknowledge limitations, and remain reasonably consistent when circumstances change.

This does not require perfection. Everyone occasionally makes promises they cannot keep, responds poorly under pressure, or misunderstands another person’s needs.

The important distinction is what happens afterward.

Does the person acknowledge the mistake without excessive defensiveness? Do they make a reasonable effort to repair the consequences? Does the experience influence their future behavior?

These responses provide evidence that sincerity extends beyond the original conversation.

They also explain why trust can recover after disappointment, provided people are willing to take responsibility.

An apology may begin the process, but reliable behavior is what makes the apology increasingly believable.

Practicing What We Want Others to Believe

Perhaps the most useful way to think about sincerity is as a collection of small disciplines rather than a personality characteristic.

It involves recognizing when we are about to agree merely to avoid conflict, resisting the temptation to promise what we cannot deliver, and listening carefully enough that another person’s experience can influence our understanding.

It also means learning to communicate uncertainty without embarrassment and disagreement without unnecessary hostility.

None of these skills is particularly glamorous. Most will never attract recognition or make someone appear exceptionally charismatic.

But together, they produce something increasingly valuable: relationships in which people do not have to spend enormous energy interpreting our intentions.

There is a quiet freedom in knowing that someone’s words are generally reliable, that their kindness does not conceal a different agenda, and that difficult conversations will not automatically threaten the relationship.

I suspect this is why sincerity matters so much to emotional intelligence. Emotional awareness gives us the ability to understand how people feel. Sincerity determines whether we use that understanding responsibly.

The distinction becomes visible over time.

The people we trust most are rarely those who have mastered the performance of caring. They are the ones whose behavior has made caring believable.

And that is something worth practicing, particularly when nobody is watching and there is nothing to gain from appearing sincere.

CHECK OUT THIS WEEK’S DEEP DIVES BOOK SUMMARY

If You Liked This Article, You May Also Like …